Microreactor for Grignard Reagents Flow Reactor Instead of Stirred-Tank: Problems with Grignard Reactions Eliminated
Victor Grignard was awarded the Nobel Prize for Chemistry in 1912. Since then, the Grignard reagents named after him have become firmly established in the chemical and pharmaceutical industries. A new type of microreactor developed by Fraunhofer researchers makes these reactions faster and safer and the products purer.
Mainz/Germany — Many of today’s pharmaceuticals, fragrances and flavorings are produced by means of reactions with Grignard reagents. Discovered more than 100 years ago, these compounds provide one of the most effective means of creating chemical bonds between carbon atoms. Among the top 50 active pharmaceutical ingredients, one in ten has a synthesis pathway that includes one or more Grignard reactions. There is a drawback, however: depending on the type of reaction, it can take some time for the reaction to get properly started — and, once it does, the reaction very quickly generates a lot of heat, which then has to be dissipated. To restrict the generation of heat, the reagent is only added to the continuous stirred-tank reactor in limited portions. This, however, lengthens the reaction time, during which a lot of byproducts can form. Should, for example, the desired product happen to react with the starting material, this can result in contamination, thereby lowering product quality and/or yield.
Continuous Process Control: Faster, Safer, Cleaner
Researchers at the Fraunhofer Institute for Microengineering and Microsystems IMM in Mainz have now succeeded in eliminating these problems. They have replaced the large continuous stirred-tank reactor with a flow reactor. According to Dr. Gabriele Menges-Flanagan, research fellow at Fraunhofer IMM, this means that it is now possible to use the full power of the reaction and still control the temperature wonderfully. This method has a number of advantages. Whereas in the continuous stirred-tank reactor, the reaction takes a long time; in the flow reactor, the entire reagent is converted in a matter of minutes. Furthermore, product purity is higher, and produced amounts can be tailored to requirements. In other words, the process is not only faster and safer, but it also delivers a cleaner product.
These advantages are down to the reactor design. Inside the flow reactor, the reactant — usually an organic bromide or chloride — is pumped up through a bed of magnesium shavings. An abundance of magnesium shavings in the reactor ensures that the reaction gets going properly and then progresses in a controlled manner. Crucial here, too, is the geometry of the reactor, which features a double-skinned cylinder, cooled on the inside and outside skin by a continuous flow of oil. This ensures that the heat from the reaction is dissipated quickly and efficiently, thereby not only enhancing safety but also inhibiting the production of undesirable byproducts. The fact that both reactant and product flow through the reactor with short residence times also inhibits side reactions.
There are two reasons for this: on the one hand, the reactant is rapidly converted into product; on the other, this product flows continuously through the reactor – rather than, as in the past, swimming together with the reactant in a continuous stirred-tank reactor. In other words, there are far fewer opportunities for side reactions between the two. The abundance of magnesium in the flow reactor also helps prevent side reactions. This is because the reactant is more likely to react with the magnesium shavings than with the product, which is rapidly removed.
A Scalable and Flexible Pilot Plant
Researchers have already built a pilot plant, which can convert up to 20 liters of reactant solution an hour. This can be run either for short periods or continuously, depending on the volume of product required. Should larger volumes of product be required, another option is to run a number of reactor modules together. The current pilot plant consists of four such modules and marks an important interim stage on the way towards boosting throughput and, ultimately, achieving industrial-scale production. Researchers from Fraunhofer have already teamed up with partners from industry to carry out initial feasibility studies. “Industry feedback has informed the entire development process, from lab scale to pilot plant,” Menges-Flanagan confirms. She also says that a pilot project with customers from industry at their site is feasable in around a year’s time.
As well as being suitable for the formation of any conceivable type of Grignard reagent, the plant should also prove suitable, in the long term, for the synthesis of organometallic compounds of zinc. Indeed, researchers have already conducted such reactions on the lab scale. Using the new reactor, it should be possible for the first time ever to make these reactions flexibly scalable.